Project Review Rubric

From GeoClasses

Comments will be made on the discussion page of the project. To comment answer the following questions. DO NOT give any numerical or letter grade for the project, but write specific answers to these questions.

• Remember, part of your grade depends on the quality of your review.

Editorial content

1. Are all the images correctly referenced and come from public domain sources?
   • How to tell if an image is in the public domain
2. Are the spelling and grammar correct?
3. Does the text make sense?
4. Are there at least 4 references?

Scientific content

1. Does the abstract accurately describe the content of the project?
2. Is the information provided accurate to the best of your knowledge?
3. Are there any scientific terms used in the project that are not adequately described?
4. Is there anything missing given the topic of this project?
5. What outstanding questions do you have about the project?

Summary statements

1. Describe at least one thing the project got right. Explain why you think this.
2. Describe at least one thing the project got wrong or that you think the authors could have done better. Explain your reasoning.
3. Summarize your opinion of the project.